Cheque bounce cases are one of the most common legal issues faced by individuals and businesses in India. With the increasing use of negotiable instruments for commercial transactions, instances of dishonoured cheques have also surged. In this context, a common question arises—is partial payment a valid defence in cheque bounce cases? This article delves deep into this legal query under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, supported by judicial precedents, and offers expert insight from Advocatepooja, a seasoned bounced cheque lawyer in Navi Mumbai.
Introduction to Cheque Bounce Cases
A case of cheque bounce arises when a cheque issued by the drawer is returned unpaid by the bank. Common reasons for dishonour include insufficient funds, mismatched signatures, or a closed account. In India, cheque bounce is a criminal offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
The section aims to promote the credibility of cheques in financial transactions and to ensure that obligations undertaken by way of cheques are honoured in a timely manner.
Elements of a Valid Cheque Bounce Case
Before assessing the role of partial payment as a defence, it is essential to understand what constitutes a legally valid cheque bounce case:
- The cheque must be drawn for the discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability.
- It must be presented within three months from the date of issue.
- The cheque must be returned unpaid due to insufficient funds or other bank reasons.
- The payee must send a written demand notice within 30 days of receiving the bank memo.
- The drawer fails to make the payment within 15 days from receipt of the notice.
Failure to comply with any of these conditions may weaken the complainant’s case.
What Is Partial Payment?
Partial payment refers to the payment of a portion of the total amount due. In legal terms, it can be either:
- Made before issuing the cheque
- Made after issuing the cheque but before its presentation
- Made after the cheque has bounced
Each of these scenarios is evaluated differently by the courts under the purview of Section 138.
Is Partial Payment a Valid Defence?
Let’s break this down:
1. Partial Payment Before Issuance of Cheque
If a cheque is issued after accounting for a previous partial payment, and the cheque reflects the remaining legally enforceable debt, then the drawer cannot claim a defence. The liability is considered valid under Section 138.
2. Partial Payment After Cheque Is Issued but Before Presentation
This is the most controversial and legally significant aspect.
Judicial Insight:
In M/s Indus Airways Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s Magnum Aviation Pvt. Ltd. (2014), the Supreme Court observed that if a part payment is made after the cheque is drawn, the drawer must endorse this on the cheque as per Section 56 of the NI Act.
Failure to do so means that the cheque does not represent the correct enforceable debt. This could potentially invalidate a Section 138 prosecution because the cheque no longer reflects the true debt amount.
Recent Ruling:
In Rajesh Agarwal vs State, the Delhi High Court clarified that any payment made after the cheque has been issued cannot retrospectively alter the liability mentioned in the cheque unless it is legally endorsed.
So yes, partial payment can be a valid defence, only if it alters the legally enforceable debt and the cheque does not reflect the updated amount.
3. Partial Payment After Dishonour
Any payment made after the cheque has bounced does not serve as a valid defence. It can be considered for compounding or mitigation of punishment, but it won’t invalidate the criminality under Section 138.
Practical Example
Suppose Mr. A owes Mr. B ₹1,00,000. Mr. A pays ₹20,000 in cash and issues a cheque for ₹80,000. Mr. B presents the cheque, which is dishonoured. Mr. A cannot argue that he had already paid ₹20,000 if the cheque was issued afterward and represents the correct debt.
But if Mr. A issued a cheque of ₹1,00,000 and made a ₹20,000 payment after the cheque issuance but before its presentation, and does not endorse this on the cheque, then Mr. B presenting the cheque for ₹1,00,000 could be challenged.
New Cheque Bounce Rules in India
The government has introduced several changes to address cheque bounce cases more effectively. Some recent developments include:
- Time-bound trials for cheque bounce cases
- Introduction of electronic cheque bounce notices
- Scope for compounding even at higher appellate stages
- Stricter penalties for repeat offenders
Check bouncing charges can also vary from bank to bank but may include penalty fees from both the drawer and payee’s banks. Legal fees and court costs can also add to the burden.
Advocatepooja’s Expert Opinion
As an experienced bounced cheque lawyer, Advocatepooja states:
“Many accused persons do not understand the implications of partial payments. Courts look into whether the cheque reflects the actual legally enforceable debt. In some cases, partial payments made after issuance can indeed become a valid ground for defence, but only if proven appropriately.”
She further advises her clients to document all partial payments, keep acknowledgements, and if required, endorse payments on the cheque to avoid legal disputes.
How to Defend Yourself in a Cheque Bounce Case
If you are facing a cheque bounce allegation and you’ve made a partial payment, follow these steps:
- Collect evidence of the payment (bank transfer receipts, emails, WhatsApp chats).
- Consult an expert bounced cheque lawyer like Advocatepooja to draft a detailed reply.
- File for quashing under Section 482 CrPC if the case is frivolous.
- Respond to the legal notice within 15 days explaining the partial payment with proof.
- If charges are framed, present your defence during trial proceedings.
Role of a Bounced Cheque Lawyer
A specialist like Advocatepooja can help you in:
- Scrutinizing legal notices
- Preparing reply with legal citations
- Filing petitions for quashing
- Representing you in magistrate court
- Negotiating compounding of offence
- Minimizing check bouncing charges and penalties
Final Thoughts
To conclude, partial payment is a complex but potentially valid defence in cheque bounce cases, depending on timing and documentary proof. With the evolving legal landscape and strict implementation of the new cheque bounce rules, accused individuals must take prompt legal steps.
If you’re facing a case of cheque bounce or want legal guidance about check bouncing charges or any related issue, Advocatepooja, a trusted name among cheque bounce lawyers in Navi Mumbai, can provide you with precise legal assistance.
Call Now: [9920456025]
Visit Us – Advocatepooja Law Office, Navi Mumbai
Expert Legal Help in 30 Minutes Guaranteed!
